Through blogs and comments, patients and experts explore what it takes to find good health care and make the most of it.

Four Perfect Questions


In the fall of 2010, Atul Gawande, surgeon at Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston and an associate professor at Harvard Medical School, delivered a touching speech at the October New Yorker Festival.'  My husband attended with a friend and, because he said it so profoundly impacted the audience, I watched it myself on video the next day. It was indeed amazing. Dr. Gawande, author and national health care presence, spoke unabashedly about his lack of skill in conducting end-of-life conversations with his patients.

How could that kind of conversation ever be easy?'  I remember when my father-in-law passed away nine years ago.'  A nervous young doctor had the uncomfortable task of telling him that nothing more could be done about his leukemia and it was perhaps time for hospice.'  As he stumbled through the explanation, my father-in-law let him off the hook easily by saying 'Well, hell son, I didn't think I'd live forever.' ' It wasn't the doctor initiating an end-of-life conversation, but rather the patient reassuring the doctor by simply announcing, albeit a bit theatrically, that he understood what was going on and he was ready.

In the 2010 presentation, Dr. Gawande talked about how he searched for a way to help his patients understand, accept, and know when they are ready.'  He spoke with several end-of-life physicians who told them how they do it every day.

Ultimately, one physician, Dr. Susan Block at Dana Farber Institute, gave a simple, straightforward, and elegant answer that resonated.'  She told Dr. Gawande that there are four questions she mentally carries around that guide her through the difficult but important conversations. And those conversations are not about sophisticated hard choices or last minute 'epiphanies.' Instead, they are about the process of understanding hopes and fears.

Here are her four questions:

Do you understand your prognosis? What are your fears about what is to come? What are your goals as time runs out? What trade offs are you willing to make?

Four perfect questions.

After seeing the video eighteen months ago, I scribbled those four questions onto a torn scrap of paper and tossed it into a stack of things that I would, like Scarlett O'Hara, think about tomorrow.

But once in a while, I unearth it unexpectedly and then pause to consider the genius of Dr. Block.'  Sometimes it is because I wonder if I may personally face the end-of-life choices sooner than I ever expected.'  At other times, what really strikes me is that the questions are also about the process of recognizing hopes and fears in every day life.'  Think about the daily choices and hard decisions, especially the unexpected ones, that we are faced with. And with each one we have to ask ourselves what is going on; what scares us about it; what do we ultimately want to accomplish; and what are we willing to do or sacrifice to make it happen?

Four perfect questions.

They came to the forefront again recently when I read about a family physician, Dr. Ken Murray, who wrote a Wall Street Journal' essay titled 'Why Doctors Die Differently.' ' He observed that doctors are more likely than other people to decline end-of-life interventions that have little likelihood of benefit.

It's not something that we like to talk about, but doctors die, too. What's unusual about them is not how much treatment they get compared with most Americans, but how little. They know exactly what is going to happen, they know the choices, and they generally have access to any sort of medical care that they could want. But they tend to go serenely and gently.

Dr. Murray goes on to talk about the importance of advance directives and all the other technical issues that must be addressed. But those not withstanding, I have to wonder if doctors tend to go serenely and gently because they have spent years, by virtue of what they do and see, knowingly answering those questions for themselves.

I recently shared the questions with a friend who is close with someone facing an end-of-life situation.'  She was amazed by their simplicity and perfection, and I realized what a small but meaningful gift it is to help someone accept what is to come with grace and dignity.

It was eye opening. It made me think about the fact that one day, we will all be faced with the end-of-life. And so, perhaps today we might promise ourselves for the sake of spouses, partners, family, and friends to make an effort to understand what can truly happen to us, to acknowledge our fears, to plan what we want to do with whatever time we have and to know what trade offs we are willing to make.

They are indeed, four perfect questions.


More Blog Posts by Elaine Waples

author bio

Elaine Waples underwent major abdominal surgery in 2010 for stage 3 primary peritoneal (ovarian) cancer that had metastasized to several organs. Since then she has undergone years of a robust treatment regimen including 8 rounds of chemotherapy. Her journey is chronicled on the online health care magazine Care and Costs, edited by her husband, Brian Klepper.

Tags for this article:
End-of-Life Planning   Plan for your End of Life Care   Aging Well   Elaine Waples  

Comments on this post
Please note: CFAH reserves the right to moderate all comments posted to the Prepared Patient® Blog. Any inappropriate postings will be removed.

Ellen says
July 11, 2013 at 3:02 PM

Thank you, Elaine, for so bravely sharing your story to help others, and thank you, Jessie, for sharing the Four Perfect Questions.

In 2008, I met Dr. Jill Bolte Taylor when I was attending the TED conference she spoke at. Her story of her stroke, which happily did not turn out to be the end of her life, so moved me that I wanted to share her story as widely as possible. I brought out her book, My Stroke of Insight, which I highly recommend on this subject, and we are turning her story into a major feature film now.

Jill then introduced me to Dr. Lauren Van Scoy and her book. Dr. Van Scoy's perspective is different - she is a doctor who helps people through their end of life experiences every day. She has seen "good" deaths and deaths that are at the opposite end of the spectrum. We all die, but there is a tremendous difference in the experience, and a large factor influencing that is preparedness.

Dr. Van Scoy wrote a book called "Last Wish: Stories to Inspire a Peaceful Passing" which is her patients' stories. As soon as I read it, I felt compelled to publish it too to share these valuable stories and Dr. Van Scoy's wisdom with others.

Some have good death experiences and some do not. Reading these stories can help us all have quality of life and peace all the way through our last breaths. The book will help us, and also allow us to help our loved ones.

In addition to the guidance from the stories, Dr. Van Scoy developed a planning tool called the "Last Wish Compass" and she offers it as a tear-out in her book. She helps us realize that Advance Directives and Living Wills by themselves are not sufficient. We really need her Compass too. I can't recommend more highly both Dr. Van Scoy's book, Last Wish, and also her Last Wish Compass, to help us all be better prepared.

Thank you again for all the incredible work you're doing, Jessie, and that you took the time to share it with all of us.

Ellen Stiefler
Transmedia Books, a division of Transmedia Multiverse, LLC