Through blogs and comments, patients and experts explore what it takes to find good health care and make the most of it.

Guest Blog: High Health Cost Does Not Guarantee Quality


The new buzzword in Medicine these days is "value based purchasing". It's not a new concept...everyone wants to get their money's worth, whether it is a new car, a meal at a fancy restaurant or the best medical care. Without clear information on quality, however, many patients assume that more expensive care is better care.

The Agency for Health Care Research and Quality (AHCRQ) has funded a study to look at this. A team of researchers studied how various presentations of cost and quality influenced the choices of patients. They found that many people perceived low cost clinicians to be substandard and avoided them. It didn't matter if they were paying out of pocket for care or if they had insurance that covered the service. They still associated higher cost with higher quality care.

When patients were given information in the form of easy to understand data about care quality they were more likely to make choices that didn't cost more. It mattered how the data was presented.

Americans spend more on their health care than citizens of 12 other developed nations, but the quality of that care (as measured in outcomes, accessibility, preventive care) lags far behind. It is difficult for a patient to know what "quality" care is. According to Peter Lee, the former chief executive of the Pacific Business Group on Health, "For most consumers, the fact that there is no connection between quality and cost is one of the dirty secrets of medicine."

Most people don't have the time or expertise to delve into finding out if their doctor, hospital or surgeon can deliver "value" for the cost. There are a number of websites that compare hospital outcomes for surgeries, infections and treatments but they are cumbersome and the data can be 2 or more years old. Essentially they are useless for the patient.

Until we can:
1. Define quality
2. Provide transparent data that is easy to understand and
3. Provide pricing and costs that are easy to understand

We will never be able to bring the escalating cost of health care under control. Until that time, patients are flying blind and hoping that their high cost care delivers something in return that they can value.

More Blog Posts by Toni Brayer

author bio

Toni Brayer is an Internal Medicine physician who has practiced for over 20 years in Northern California. She was previously the President of the SF Medical Society and Chief of Staff at a large academic medical center. Brayer is currently the Chief Medical Officer for a large hospital/physician System in Northern California. She blogs on EverythingHealth. You can follow her on Twitter @chieftb.

Tags for this article:
Health Care Cost   Pay for your Health Care   Toni Brayer  

Comments on this post
Please note: CFAH reserves the right to moderate all comments posted to the Prepared Patient® Blog. Any inappropriate postings will be removed.

No comments have been entered yet.